The original Xbox controller, lovingly called the Duke by both its fans and detractors for its massive size, might be making a comeback. Original Xbox designer Seamus Blackley asked his Twitter followers to engage in a thought experiment: “If we worked with [Phil Spencer] to release an official Xbox One-compatible Duke, would you buy one?”

Apparently, though, that wasn’t so much an experiment. Blackley tweeted this week that he is “doing actual work to see if we can release a new Duke,” asking fans to stay tuned and to amplify his message if they’re interested.

Who would buy this thing?

It’s hard to see exactly who the Duke would be for, though. While it had its fans, the Xbox S controller that followed it later was…